I write about digital strategies and communications — and their intersection with culture, politics, journalism and social activism.


19 Essential Social Media Tools

So useful . . . thanks to Adsquad



Social Media Fails: Not so Tough to Manage

(This post was originally published last week on the Conference Board of Canada's 'Hot Topics in Technology and Innovation' blog, in anticipation of my presentation at its Public Sector Social Media 2015 conference in Ottawa October 27-28, 2015)

Pick any week in any month and you’ll likely sight a company or organization facing an issue or crisis that has the social web as its battlefield.

Hacks (Ashley Madison). Twitter rants (Tinder v. Vanity Fair). Twitter fights (Herbalife v. @AfueraHerbaLIES). Online shamings (Walter Palmer and Cecil the lion). . . . And that’s just a few weeks in the summer, and doesn’t include the ever-more-commonplace missteps (rudeness, incidental racism or sexism etc.) by social media community managers that don’t make it to the front pages of legacy media.

In crisis management we used to say there are those organizations that have faced a crisis and there are those that will. A bit glib for the time maybe. But with the social web today it verges on certainty. At some time, on some social platform someone will say something nasty about your organization (or you personally).

My colleague who runs our issues and crisis practice likes to remind me that the principles for effective crisis and issues management even on the social web don’t really change. And in large part she’s right. Be honest; be compassionate; and respond quickly, for example, apply in any crisis.

But there are some nuances with social that are worth keeping in mind.  

Negativity on social is endemic. Platforms like Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram allow people to express pleasure or dissatisfaction with a person, product or service . . . and express it loudly and with, in many cases, a great deal of vitriol, even obscenity.

But many are just one-time-only outbursts, in which the damage to an organization’s or individual’s reputation MAY BE — and I stress MAY BE — minimal and not likely to last.

Not every nasty call to a customer hotline or angry consumer at the check out represents a reputational crisis, for example. In the same way, not every negative sentiment expressed on social media calls for a reaction, and not every comment that begs for a reaction represents a crisis.

Of course, the challenge for many organizations is assessing which comments are unusual, delimited or token and which ones can undercut years of organizational brand building.

Here are a few questions to help you assess the situation and come up with a response strategy:

  1. Can the issue be taken offline for a resolution? Offline can put a halt to any social amplification
  2. Is this the type of comment that might interest local or national media? Commenters often tag media in their post or tweet in an effort to get a company's attention. When print or broadcast media pick up a negative strain in social it becomes a 'story' and gains a heightened level of intensity.
  3. Is the commenter or customer influential within his or her community? There are some easy tools—Klout among them—that give you a snapshot of whether someone's comment is worth paying attention to.
  4. Is the commenter a serial complainer or over-active tweeter or poster? Their comments can sometimes get lost in their own noise.
  5. Was the underlying problem our fault, or have we seen similar negative sentiment in the past that suggests an operational or reputation problem? You should fix it and say you are doing so . . . on the social platform being used for the complaint.
  6. Can we apologize on social for the problem we’ve caused if that is the root of the adverse sentiment? An authentic and honest apology (see my blog post on how NOT to say it) is pivotal to protecting reputation.
  7. Are we in a position to continue to trade comments with the source of the negative sentiment? You'll need writing resources that know how to manage social web dialogue.

Some of these questions are going to be difficult to answer if your organization is unfamiliar or uncomfortable with social web dynamics.

But this self-assessment, undertaken before you need it, may not only better prepare you to respond when the day comes that your name is being dragged through the social mud, but also educate you about what’s expected for effective social web interaction day-to-day.